Skip to main content

Mathematical Dogma and Euler's identity

Euler's identity is as misunderstood, as it is misattributed. Euler himself never committed the equation to paper.

Firstly, it is not an identity as the values are not absolute.

Secondly, major misconceptions in mathematics arise from the unspoken rules, in this case that the symbol = means equal to a given value of significance.

E.g. 3.456432 = 3.4563456 (to 4 s.f.)

To one significant figure both numbers would be 3. To five significant figures they are no longer equal. 

The equation e^{\pi i}+1=0 involves {e}, {\pi}, and {\i}, which are irrational and unreal numbers respectively. Raising these numbers to each other is not going to make them absolutely equal to anything, infinitely close yes, but not an absolute value.

If we use algebra laws on Euler's identity it fails immediately and we see e^{\pi i} = -1. 

This means to one significant figure, the answer was negative one, however adding the arbitrary absolute value of 1 to the equation created an inequality and a value infinitesimally small, but still greater than zero.

Going back to our algebraic rules and actual identities we know that e^{pi i} = (e^\pi)^\i. 

If we take the i root of both sides, we get e^\pi = \i \sqrt{-1}. 

Dividing both sides by \i \sqrt{-1}, we find e^\pi / \i \sqrt{-1} = 1.

Now we have equivalence to an absolute value and this is the true essence of Euler's identity.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Degree Assignments

  Richard Thompson – 160202828 – BA (Hons) Education and Personal Development – EPD52 Exploring unified educational theory and the fallacy of “general pedagogical knowledge”.   Personal Journal Entry 20191227 : New words and ideas are fun toys we rush to play with, gifting power to the initiated (Frye, 2012, p. 101) , although this is often nothing more than a conceit.   If we consider the possibility that learners initially perceive the world through the lens of their passions, but lack merely the appropriate vocabulary to translate and articulate this to their audience, (Whiskey Vault, 2019) can we honestly say they are any less developed in their understanding of the fundamental concept?   By labouring to a proscribed outcome, do we not risk increasing disjuncture   (Jarvis, 2010) to the point where it gains the French quality of “ barbarique” which Frye translated as ‘something we can’t be bothered trying to understand.’ (2012, p. 96) .   Thro...
Post a Comment
Read more

Reflective Piece: Shaped by Place, Time — and a Mind That Wouldn’t Sit Still

I was born at the end of August 1976, in Rotherham — a town that carries the memory of steelworks, coal mines, and the working-class backbone that once powered Britain’s industry. From the moment I took my first breath, my life has been stitched into the social fabric of a community built on resilience, pride, and a deep sense of solidarity. Like many from South Yorkshire, my sense of fairness and loyalty was forged in the shadow of the miners’ strike, the steelworkers strikes and the slow decline of local industries. These weren’t just news stories — they were the conversations around the kitchen table, the picket lines, the harsh lessons that taught me that when systems fail, you stand by your own. Growing up with inattentive ADHD, though undiagnosed for decades, meant my mind was always wandering — always half-here, half-somewhere-else. At school, the labels stuck: lazy, away with the fairies, not living up to potential. My handwriting — “less legible than if a spider had run th...
Post a Comment
Read more